The Boston Musical Intelligencer
2025
Memory Speaks Movingly

Perhaps some year a gala honoring the artists and musicians who suffered at the Terezin propaganda factory/camp/ghetto will not feel raw and immediate. Sad to say, much of the world continues to treat fellow beings as less than human. The Terezin Music Foundation’s program “Liberation” at Symphony Hall kept alive the memory of the artists who passed through this “model camp” and reminded us of what is lost when lives are cut short. Sunday’s program also marked the celebration of the 80th anniversary of the liberation of the approximately 42,000 concentration camps throughout Europe and was dedicated to the memory of one of TMF’s staunchest advocates, survivor Anna Ornstein. TMF Director Mark Ludwig provided the essential narrative descriptions of the works performed in her honor.
Linda Bussgang and pianist Victor Cayres opened with three beautiful Yiddish protest songs from World War II. Bussgang’s gorgeous voice was particularly effective on the third song as she embodied a child singing about fighting for freedom. Erwin Schullhoff, a Czech composer of Jewish descent, was well known in his lifetime, but his works have faded from prominence since his death in a German jail in 1942. His music had been labelled as degenerate, and he was forced until the time of his arrest, to make a scant living as a radio pianist or under an assumed name. His musical influences included the French impressionists, ragtime, jazz, and Dadist absurdity. All of these were on display in his Hot-Sonate: Jazz for Alto Saxophone and Piano (1930). Movement 1 was a chatty cafe waltz, optimistic and busy in the style of American in Paris. Movements 2 and 3 expressed some of the sinuous blues influences reminiscent of Rhapsody in Blue. The final movement had a relentless urgency, with harmonic minor, Klezmer-influenced wild melodies, surrounding a more pastoral and ruminative central section. Saxophonist Philipp Stäudlin and pianist Yoko Hagino collaborated in a polished performance.
A Sonata for solo piano by Gideon Klein (Terezin, 1943) and Beeethoven’s Piano Sonata No. 31, Op. 110 in A-flat Major (1797) closed the concert. Beth Levin is a pianist of rare gifts. Her ability to tease melody from a thick fabric of sound is phenomenal; we witnessed some of the finest imaginable voice leading and musical dialogue among her ten fingers. Gideon Klein wrote his sonata while imprisoned at Terezin. The letters he sent home to his family begged them to remember him despite his probably certain knowledge of his ultimate fate, perishing in Auschwitz’s work camp. This work alone would make that plea a necessary imperative.
In Levin’s hands, the first movement’s atonal and angular melodic lines seemed connected and tonal. She clarified how the “atonality” of the Second Viennese school composers logically extended the late German Romantic composers. The second movement was a misty and inward-looking reverie, while the third was more of a Devil’s dance with relentless trills. The final movement, filled with rage and a final clanging tritone like an ambulance, stood out for its emotionally, conveying a real reflection of what Klein must have felt and seen. Klein had performed the Beethoven sonata before his internment, though, due to the Nuremberg Racial Laws, he had to work under the name Karol Bronek. It is always disturbing to think that the same culture that gave rise to Beethoven, Bach, and Brahms, also brought forth the horrors of the Holocaust. How our paths can lead to inhumanity should never be forgotten.
Levin gave a very personal and eye-opening interpretation. The first movement sounded gentle and sweet, with clear voice leading. Rather than the bombastic robustness of some performances, it rather conveyed a thoughtful intelligence that made Beethoven’s stark contrasts all the grander. The smooth and melodic second movement again came across with superb voice leading. The solemn Adagio melted into the fugal passages like incense smoke rising to the roof of a great cathedral, caught in color and light, building in intensity. After the return of the Adagio, the energy and power of the second fugue showed the logic in the quieter moments of the opening. The sound of the piano filled Symphony Hall triumphantly.
Overall, a worthy evening celebrating an always-important cause.
Ed. Note: Indeed, the author erred in citing a Schubert sonata instead of the Beethoven op. 110. Now corrected.
Elisa Birdseye, executive director of the Boston Chamber Ensemble, is an active freelance violist and principal violist of the New Bedford Symphony. Additionally, she has worked as the general manager of the New England Philharmonic and Boston Musica Viva.